2024 02 22 steering group minutes
| Topic | Relevant Links and to do |
|---|---|
| BEP for dimensionality reduction-based networks | Peer Herholz |
| Avoiding BEP being stuck | Issue with Atlas BEP - circulate the idea of revising BEP development - one point missing in those discussions is how to get unstuck if conflict (CP: item voting is my favorite option, we just need the mechanism for it - like we do to elect this group) |
| Cooperation with DICOM standard | YOH pointed David Clunie to our DICOMs deficits table , he forwarded to WG-16 to consider at the next meeting. |
| Updates on plan for website | BIDS Online Presence Working Group: Working Document |
| BIDS 2.0 going forward! | |
| BEP guidelines updating (Camille & Remi) | https://github.com/bids-standard/bids-extensions/pull/28 |
Present: Yarik, Kim, Ariel, Cyril, Eric, Christine, Camille
Apologies: Dora
Guest: Peer Herholz
BIDS Meeting Notes
Plan for website
- Eric is chairing the BIDS Online Presence Working Group
- Eric owes the open letter to the Steering Group
- May use google season of docs (need to sign up for the program, starts April 2nd for applications)
- Will reach out to INCF to reconnect as the admin for google season of docs
- Mentors identified: Eric, Christine, and Remi (outlined in doc linked in agenda)
- Eric will reach out to the group to schedule a follow up meeting.
- Yaroslav reminded the group that he has \$5k CAD to compensate for work on this project
BEP39 for dimensionality reduction-based networks
-
May need to introduce new terminology (something akin to an 'index', param-mixing, param-components, something akin to 'model')
-
Eric suggests instead of \'index' potentially like _aslcontext.tsv
-
map : discussion determined modality is a suffix - Related discussion bids-2-devel/issues/58#issuecomment-1711758273
-
'model-ICA_description.json' : suggestion to rename file as 'dataset_dscription.json' and include 'DatasetType: model" and model-ICA_mfp.json similarly to 'task-xxx_bold.json
-
Current state is to build up and extend \'spatiotemporal decompositions' introduced in BEP 012
-
Interoperability : BIDS-Prov
-
BEP028_BIDSprov/blob/master/examples/from_parsers/spm/spm_default_batch.jsonld#L65-L77
-
Software parameters is similar to BIDS-prov's Parameters description (what is the specific file?)
Stalled BEPS
Should there be a mechanism for addressing conflicts that halt BEP progress?
Suggestion:
-
a voting system similar to how the steering group is elected. How would we want to implement something like this while addressing concerns of FAIRness?
-
BEP leader determines how to move forward.
-
Could a technical committee make these decisions? (maintainers + steering group) - if there is quorum possibility to vote one way or the other**
When do we modify the schema to address new ideas?